Butterscotch Finds a Sleeper in Blumenschein Portrait

November 2023

A stylized portrait of a woman by Mary Shepard Greene Blumenschein (1869-1958) offered in Butterscotch Auction Gallery’s November 19 auction was a surprising result, soaring past its $2/3,000 estimate to bring $50,800.

Signed and dated 1914, the oil on canvas was in its original giltwood frame…

Early Portrait of Elizabeth I Leads Butterscotch's $1 Million Auction

November 2021

More than 800 lots from local estates crossed the block at Butterscotch Auction on November 21. Headlined by a painting now believed to be a lifetime portrait of Queen Elizabeth I, which sold to a buyer in the room at Historic Hall for $158,661…

Hot Bidding Spirals Upwards At Butterscotch Auction

March 2017

BEDFORD, N.Y. — With 770 lots in a one-day sale, Butterscotch Auction’s March 18 whirlwind provided a little bit of everything. Bidders were offered fine art that spanned Old Masters to Modern works, furniture from the Eighteenth to the Twentieth Century, ephemera, Asian works, carpets, estate jewelry and, of course, plenty of surprises....

Classic & Contemporary Chinese Art Excites Bidders, Busts Estimates

November 2016

BEDFORD, N.Y. — Estate fine art dominated a single-session auction conducted by Butterscotch Auction Gallery at Bedford Historical Hall on November 6. Headlining the sale was a mixed media on silk-lined paper of figures by a coastal residence attributed to Feng Zikai (Chinese, 1898–1975), which sold for $180,000....

Fine Art of a Father's Day Sale

June 2016

BEDFORD, N.Y. — It was a sunny and warm Father’s Day in this picturesque Westchester County village on June 19, but that did not keep serious collectors at home as a still life with carnations, a bird’s nest and other flowers and insects by Jan Van Huysum (Dutch, 1682–1749) elicited a robust price and enthusiastic applause inside Historical Hall. Just 20 lots in from a diverse estate sale...

Authenticating Beethoven document was its own opus

December 2015

On the surface, Mel Comberiati and Brendan Ryan make an unlikely pair of sleuths: a passionate professor of music and his former student, a composer of classical music.

What they share is a deep love and respect for the work of Ludwig van Beethoven.

Comberiati, who teaches at Manhattanville College...

Beethoven Musical Manuscript Scores $120,000 At Butterscotch Auction

November 2015

A newly discovered autograph sketchleaf by Ludwig van Beethoven headlined Butterscotch Auction’s November 22 sale at Historic Hall, selling for $120,000 including premium.

The sketchleaf was discovered by one of the gallery’s appraisers, Brendan Ryan, in a Greenwich, Conn., home....

Beethoven, Rare Steichen & American Art Earn Applause

November 2015

Observing the staff of Butterscotch Auction Gallery assemble and conduct an auction amid the quirky nooks and crannies of Bedford’s Historical Hall, the 1806 building owned by the Bedford Historical Society and rented out for private parties, meetings and exhibitions, is not unlike watching a well-oiled military logistics crew in action. Leading up to the November 22 auction...

Rachel Ruysch Still Life Sets Artist Record At Butterscotch

February 2012

At Butterscotch Auction Gallery’s February 12 estate auction, a monumental still life painting by the Dutch Golden-Age painter Rachel Ruysch (1664‱750) sold for $2.4 million, setting a new world record for the artist at auction. The painting was signed and dated 1700, and at 44 by 35 inches, is one of the largest Ruysch paintings to have ever come onto the market...

Miniature Chest Brings Mammoth Price in Bedford, N.Y.

July 2000

Paul Marinucci and his wife, owners of Butterscotch Auction Gallery, knew something was afoot before their July 16 estate sale as they fielded many calls for one lot: a miniature folk art chest.

“People were asking us what the buyers’ premium would be above $50,000,” said Marinucci....

Butterscotch in the Press